
“Tough on Crime” (1970 - Onward)
Episode 4 | 1h 47m 53sVideo has Audio Description
Violent crime is on the rise and Americans rally behind politicians promoting harsher punishments.
Cities are struck with poverty, drug addiction and violent crime, and communities rally behind politicians who promote harsher laws and punishments. But as these policies play out, some Americans will question the true cost of the system.
See all videos with Audio DescriptionADProblems playing video? | Closed Captioning Feedback
Problems playing video? | Closed Captioning Feedback
Episodes presented in 4K UHD on supported devices. Major funding for CRIME AND PUNISHMENT IN AMERICA was provided by The Atlantic Philanthropies, Emerson Collective, The Andrew W. Mellon Foundation, and...

“Tough on Crime” (1970 - Onward)
Episode 4 | 1h 47m 53sVideo has Audio Description
Cities are struck with poverty, drug addiction and violent crime, and communities rally behind politicians who promote harsher laws and punishments. But as these policies play out, some Americans will question the true cost of the system.
See all videos with Audio DescriptionADProblems playing video? | Closed Captioning Feedback
Where to Watch Crime and Punishment in America
Crime and Punishment in America is available to stream on pbs.org and the PBS app.
Providing Support for PBS.org
Learn Moreabout PBS online sponsorshipAnnouncer: Major funding for "Crime and Punishment in America" was provided by... The Atlantic Philanthropies, Emerson Collective, The Andrew W. Mellon Foundation, and the Park Foundation.
Major funding was also provided by the following members of The Better Angels Society: The Fullerton Family Charitable Fund, The Just Trust for Education, Allan and Shelley Holt, The Tow Foundation, and the Sozosei Foundation.
Additional support was provided by the National Endowment for the Humanities, The Arthur Vining Davis Foundations, and by The Better Angels Society members: John and Catherine Debs, Timothy Fazio, Lise Strickler and Mark Gallogly, the Laurie M. Tisch Illumination Fund, and these additional funders.
"Crime and Punishment in America" was made possible, in part, by contributions to your PBS station from Viewers Like You.
Thank you.
Viewer discretion is advised.
The following program contains mature content and graphic violence which may not be suitable for all audiences.
Reginald Dwayne Betts: What does it mean to live in a country that would only view prison as the most violent and dangerous place in the world... [Indistinct conversation, cell door shuts] and never think about the richness of humanity of the people who live there and never think about the ways in which those folks are sort of fighting on a regular basis against the desperation, against the depravity in a world that's said that they have no principles?
Some of the most principled men I've ever met have 50-year sentences in a state that didn't have parole.
The most non-violent people that I've ever met, the most generous people that I've ever met were told that you will never be free.
And they found a way not just to build a life but to build a community.
♪ Franklin Delano Roosevelt: A prison to us is no longer a bastille to keep people in indiscriminately, and our object ought to be to turn them out as better citizens than when they went into prison.
J. Edgar Hoover: The Federal Bureau of Investigation is waging a relentless warfare against crime and criminals.
Newsreel reader: The king of the gangsters is about to be taken for a ride by your Uncle Samuel.
William Parker: You see, crime in America is skyrocketing.
It is not a question of the proficiency of the police.
It's a question of the indulgences of the American people.
Policeman: Get your hands up, I said.
Drop that purse and get your hands up.
L.D.
Barkley: We are men.
We are not beasts, and we do not intend to be driven or beaten as such.
Doris Tate: We must fight for victims' rights, and we know the victims have no rights.
Speaker: The crime rate isn't going down.
Violent crime was up 10% across the country last year.
Ronald Reagan: We must make America safe again.
It's time to get these hardened criminals off the street and into jail.
Woman: How do you ask somebody to forgive you for something that is almost impossible to forgive?
Bill Clinton: When you commit a third violent crime, three strikes and you are out.
Bill Bratton: I'm sensing a fear among American police forces that we are losing the streets.
Betts: Everybody says, "Why'd you do it?"
But we never have reasons, never good ones.
♪ TV announcer: Good evening, ladies and gentlemen, and welcome to "The Advocates."
Tonight, the question is: Would we be safer from crime if we closed down most of our prisons?
William Rusher: This is simply another ripple in the great wave of permissiveness that has engulfed America in recent years.
[Soft laughter] Crime cannot be stopped altogether, but much of it can certainly be deterred by the knowledge that swift and humane punishment awaits the criminal.
That is much the safest course for the rest of us.
Beyond that, I suggest that tonight's proposal perpetuates the classic error of concentrating our attention and resources on the criminal rather than equally on his victims.
I guess all we can say is, great God, haven't we learned enough?
You know, we used to hang people in public because they picked pockets.
It's time that we learned the essential truth-- that every criminal is his own victim as well as creating another victim, that we can only deal with the devil outside us, which is our fear of crime, when we deal with the devil inside us to really understand crime, and that people who commit crime need to be helped in the best way they can.
Narrator: As the 1970s began, some Americans were challenging the assumption that locking law-breakers away kept the public safe.
They insisted the nation address the root causes of crime-- reducing poverty, limiting access to guns, and protecting civil rights-- and they argued that rehabilitation was more effective than punishment and isolation.
Rebecca McLennan: Many states were decarcerating.
They start to move people out of these large institutions and into halfway houses, low-security institutions, decentralized facilities of various kinds.
And, so, that's why criminologists and sociologists are able to say the future is decarceration and the future is now.
And there are sociologists who predicted that prisons in the not-too-distant future-- say 1971, looking forward-- would be thought of as a Victorian relic and a thing of the past.
Narrator: But America's prisons did not become a thing of the past.
After holding steady for nearly a century, the incarceration rate began to rise.
There was no one reason, no simple explanation for what happened.
Over the next three decades, as crime rates rose and fell, through economic booms and busts, under Republicans and Democrats, Americans everywhere got tough on crime, built more prisons, and locked more people away in them.
By 2008, the United States-- with less than 5% of the world's population-- would account for more than 20% of the incarcerated people on earth.
♪ There has been more violence in a prison.
In Attica, New York, about 1,000 long-term convicts today rioted, and they gained control of the maximum security prison.
Reporter: The trouble started around 9:00 this morning, just before normal visiting hours at the prison.
Nobody knows as yet just what touched it off.
33 employees are still being held by the prisoners, 11 other employees from within the compound have been hospitalized.
They were beaten during the early hours of the trouble.
State troopers aided prison guards... Narrator: When New York's maximum security prison, Attica, had opened its doors in 1931, it was hailed as a "convict's paradise."
But for the nearly 2,200 men serving time there in 1971, it was a living hell.
They were allowed one bar of soap and one roll of toilet paper per month, and permitted to shower once a week.
The state budgeted just 63 cents a day for food for each prisoner; those who did not have money to supplement their rations often went hungry.
More than half of the prisoners were Black or Hispanic.
397 out of the 398 guards and staff were white.
For months, the men inside Attica had petitioned the warden and the state's Department of Corrections, pleading with them to improve conditions.
Heather Ann Thompson: A civil rights movement is brewing on the outside of prison walls, so that everyone on the inside of Attica is increasingly aware that they actually still have human rights.
There are chapters of the Black Panther Party.
There were Young Lords party members, there were lots of activists within prison who say, "Look, all of America's social ills "are concentrated into these correctional institutions in a really profound way."
Narrator: On September 9, 1971, the men inside seized control of Attica.
They presented the state with a list of demands, including improved medical care, a democratically-elected parole board, and a general amnesty for the takeover itself.
They also invited reporters into the prison, and for five days, Americans watched the crisis unfold on the nightly news.
The people in here are treated like dogs.
Not only the Black, the Puerto Rican and the white.
And we're gonna get what we demand or we're gonna die trying.
That's right.
Thank you.
Narrator: One of the men leading the rebellion was a 21-year-old from Rochester, L.D.
Barkley.
He had been sent to Attica for driving without a license while on parole.
His original crime had been forging a $124 money order.
Barkley was just a few days from being released when he spoke to the press.
We are men!
We are not beasts, and we do not intend to be driven or beaten as such.
The entire prison populace has set forth to change forever the ruthless brutalization and disregard for the lives of the prisoners here and throughout the United States... Narrator: New York's Republican Governor Nelson Rockefeller monitored the crisis from a distance.
He was a four-term governor of New York, and he had a lot of power, you know?
But he wanted to be president.
He's afraid of being pictured as soft on crime because he wants to be a viable candidate for the Republican nomination.
That's what he wanted.
Narrator: Barkley and the other men in the yard asked for outside observers to help resolve the crisis.
We want Clarence B. Jones of the "Amsterdam News."
We want... Narrator: Among them was Clarence B. Jones, who had been Martin Luther King Jr.
's personal attorney, and was the publisher of one of the country's leading Black newspapers.
Clarence B. Jones: So, I go to Attica to be a member of this observers' committee.
We were trying to get a good faith negotiation over things like toothbrushes and how many rolls of toilet paper.
I remember saying to the prison officials, when they get incarcerated, they don't cease being human beings.
They're still human beings; they just happen to be human beings who are in jail.
I couldn't believe this was happening in the United States.
Russell G. Oswald: Now my question is, I asked earlier, when will you release the hostages?
Reporter: Among those keeping a vigil outside the prison walls-- the families of some of the 38 men held hostage.
Heather Ann Thompson: The prisoners understand that the guards they've taken hostage are the only thing that's standing between them and the state of New York retaking the prison by force.
They make sure that they are protected.
Narrator: The prisoners arranged for one of the hostages, William Quinn, who had been beaten severely in the chaos of the initial takeover, to be evacuated for medical treatment.
Outside the prison, hundreds of state troopers and off-duty correction officers from Attica and other prisons were gathering.
Some brought their personal weapons.
Others carried state-issued rifles.
Many took up positions on the roof, their guns aimed into the yard.
Thompson: These men are angry; these men are itching to get inside, ostensibly, just to rescue the hostages but also to exact revenge.
Narrator: Inside the yard, some of the hostages spoke to reporters.
Reporter: Sergeant Cunningham, now would you give us a message for Governor Nelson Rockefeller?
I certainly would.
I wish you would take any of the men that belong to us off the roof and any of the troopers out of here because if you get these shaky guys shooting off or getting up in a blooper over something, somebody's gonna get excited and then we're all gonna pay.
Narrator: On the third day of the crisis, the guard who had been evacuated died.
Roger Mudd: The death of one of the guards who had been held hostage by the rebelling inmates has hardened the position of prison officials, and there are strong indications tonight that police will be sent into the cell block in an attempt to rescue the rest of the hostages by force.
Narrator: Clarence B. Jones and the other observers left the prison.
Jones: I knew in my own mind that once we left, that the likelihood of them letting us back in was remote and that many of the people that we had seen were going to be killed.
In fact, some of the inmates knew that, too, because as we were seeking to leave, these inmates were giving me pieces of paper with the telephone number of the person I should call-- either their mother, their aunt, some member of their family-- in case they didn't make it out alive.
Narrator: On September 13th, Nelson Rockefeller gave the green light.
He wanted Attica retaken.
[Indistinct conversations] Narrator: As a helicopter flew over the yard, dropping canisters of tear gas, hundreds of state troopers and off-duty correction officers opened fire.
[Gunfire, people shouting] For 15 minutes, they shot thousands of rounds of live ammunition into the yard.
[Police saying commands indistinctly] Officer: Raise your hands on top of your head and move quietly... Jones: The tears I have in my eyes is only partially from the tear gas.
I know--I know that there are brother inmates that we spoke to in a vain effort to try to resolve this and whom we said good-bye to.
I know that they're dead.
I have no question about this, no question in my mind.
Narrator: 29 prisoners were killed, including L.D.
Barkley.
Ten of the hostages were also killed, including Sergeant Edward Cunningham.
A few hours after state troopers gained control of the prison, Governor Rockefeller placed a call to President Richard Nixon.
Narrator: State officials told the press that the ten hostages who died had been murdered by the prisoners.
Man: Let him finish.
Well, several had their throats slashed.
I don't have all the details on it.
I understand one had a chest wound that he died from.
The most violent rebellion in modern American penal history came to an end today at the maximum security prison in Attica, New York.
In the final hours of the revolt, led primarily by Blacks, the inmates murdered nine of their white hostages... Narrator: It wasn't true.
The next day, the local coroner announced that all of the people killed in the retaking of Attica-- the prisoners and the hostages-- had been shot to death.
Only correction officers and state troopers had guns that day, but the lie had already taken hold.
Thompson: That story goes out on the front page of the "New York Times."
It goes out on the front page of the "L.A.
Times."
The consequences of that lie were catastrophic.
Narrator: After Attica, although New York State implemented some prison reforms, many Americans who had supported rehabilitation and decarceration began to change their minds.
Thompson: In the wake of Attica, people who had been sympathetic to what was happening in that prison uprising were horrified.
"Those guys weren't civil rights activists; they were thugs; they were animals."
This becomes really powerful for the people who had been beating the tough on crime drum to say, "Look, prisons lock up the most violent, brutal people that just need longer and longer sentences," and the American public is open to it in no small part because of the lies told at Attica.
[Marvin Gaye vocalizing on recording] Gaye and singers: ♪ Rockets, moon shots ♪ ♪ Spend it on the have-nots ♪ ♪ Money ♪ ♪ We make it ♪ ♪ 'Fore we see it, you take it ♪ ♪ Oh, make me want to holler ♪ ♪ The way they do my life... ♪ Singer: ♪ Yeah... ♪ Narrator: In the 1970s, many American cities were in crisis.
Businesses and factories had moved to outlying areas, local tax bases plummeted, and funding for housing, schools, and social services was slashed.
Drastic cuts in federal funding made things far worse.
Middle-class families moved to the suburbs, leaving behind isolated pockets of poverty and hopelessness, where heroin addiction and crime were rising.
Rev.
Oberia Dempsey: I have seen the nation's number-one state, New York, become a state of fear for more than 18 million law-abiding citizens.
Dope pushers made this so.
75% to 80% of the crimes committed in our state's largest city are committed by drug addicts against law-abiding citizens.
Nelson Rockefeller: People are terrorized by the continued prevalence of narcotic addiction and the crime and the human destruction it breeds.
Let's tell it like it is.
We have achieved very little permanent rehabilitation.
We have got to develop an effective deterrent to the pushing of drugs.
Therefore, first, I am recommending legislation making the penalty for all illegal trafficking in hard drugs a life sentence in prison.
[Applause] Narrator: In 1973, New York passed the Rockefeller Drug Laws, the harshest drug laws in the country's history, targeting both dealers and users with severe mandatory sentences: 15 years to life for four ounces of heroin, cocaine, opium, or other narcotics; and for possession of even a trace amount, the mandatory sentence was one year.
35 other states passed similar laws.
Larry Krasner: The approach at that time was to write these very long bills that were about a maximal approach to everything: arrest more people, give them more time.
Have them in jail forever.
When you're talking about putting people away for 10 and 15 years for possession of drugs, that's nuts.
That has no relation to what could ever be effective, especially when we recognize that addiction is, actually, you know, a disease.
Narrator: All across the country, politicians began embracing more punitive policies.
Rafael A. Mangual: There was a sense in the 1960s and '70s that urban communities were getting to be fed up, that the hammer needed to come down, that we could no longer tolerate the kind of repeated criminality that we were seeing.
Because it was so brutal.
In this country, if one is Black, the chances one will be robbed are five times greater than if one is white.
A Black poor woman's chances of being raped are four times as high than those of a white woman.
I think we've had enough.
James Forman Jr.
: If you're a Black elected official in the 1970s in one of America's cities, you arrive at a time when crime has really started to explode.
And over and over again, your constituents are saying, "Do something.
Do something.
You've got to do something about it."
However, you're limited in what you can do because you're pleading to the federal government for more resources for housing, more resources for schools, more resources for jobs, but you're not getting that money.
So, what do you do?
You respond with the one thing that you can think of that the rest of the government will support you in responding with, which is police and prosecutors and prisons.
A crook is a crook is a crook, and because a crook is Black, even though Black people are racially and economically oppressed, does not give that person an excuse for preying on the Black community.
Narrator: From 1970 to 1985, the American prison population more than doubled, from nearly 200,000 to almost half a million.
♪ Pat Nolan: I'd grown up in a neighborhood that was real rough.
I and every member of my family was a victim of crime.
One time, my sister and I were walking.
These kids jumped us, knocked us down, and it really shocked me 'cause I was raised, you know, you never hit a girl.
And they were punching on her, too.
And I was just outraged.
Narrator: Pat Nolan was born in 1950 and grew up in Los Angeles.
In high school, he joined Young Americans for Freedom and volunteered for Ronald Reagan's campaign for governor.
In 1978, Nolan was elected to the California State Assembly.
Nolan: So, when I got elected to the legislature, I wanted to do something about crime because I wanted families to feel safe in their homes and in their neighborhoods, walking to school.
Many Americans are living in fear these days-- fear of the rising crime rate... Sometime tonight, probably as you sleep, a burglar will break into someone's home... Nolan: Legislators watch TV, too.
The new attorney general has said his top priority... Nolan: You know, the news-- "If it bleeds, it leads."
Major crime in America took its biggest jump in 5 years... Nolan: We're impacted by that.
There may be a murder that takes place in a city, and people that live miles from there that aren't impacted by that still feel fear because it happened locally.
It made the news.
But the fact remains crime is running rampant on every street in Milwaukee... Bryan Stevenson: So, news stations quickly learn that if you start with a story that might scare people or outrage people, people will be attracted to that.
So, every homicide, every sexual assault, every serious crime becomes the top news.
And it becomes very captivating.
Reporter: There is a crime wave on Miami Beach-- more killings, more rapes, more robberies-- and the victims are fearing for their lives.
Nolan: I thought we weren't tough enough on criminals.
My sense was that they were violent, incorrigible.
This graph shows the murder rate since the court struck down and denied us the right to execute murderers.
This has unleashed on the citizens of our state a bloodbath unparalleled.
Nolan, voice-over: I voted for every new prison.
I, on the floor, carried the bill to establish Pelican Bay, the supermax.
Now I realize, one of the big questions is not how long they should be there but how do we want them when they come out?
But in the legislature, that was never talked about.
It didn't occur to us.
[Vehicle horns honking] Bratton: When I first came into the Boston Police Department in 1970, I was assigned to Police District 3, Mattapan, which also was the location of the huge Mattapan State Hospital for the mentally ill, and on more than one occasion, had to take individuals who were seriously mentally ill to that complex in the middle of the night, sometimes in straitjackets.
Narrator: For more than 100 years, America confined people with serious mental illness in asylums and psychiatric hospitals.
Like the nation's first penitentiaries, asylums were some of the most expensive public buildings of the 19th century, built with the promise that the people confined there would be treated with dignity.
But time and again, investigations and exposés revealed that patients there were neglected and abused.
New antipsychotic medications made it possible for many patients to be discharged, and in the 1960s, states began to shutter their psychiatric hospitals, planning to replace them with community mental health centers.
Bratton: We closed those facilities for budgetary purposes, for humane purposes, and the idea was we were going to return the mentally ill to neighborhood treatment centers, where they could be close to their families.
But it didn't happen.
Most of those centers never opened.
Narrator: Federal and State governments never allocated adequate funds for community-based care.
Without treatment, hundreds of thousands of men and women ended up on the streets.
Bratton: Schizophrenia, bipolar, sometimes influenced by drugs.
But who was expected to deal with it at 3:00 in the morning?
The police, who are not trained to deal with it.
Six months' training in the academy, he's being asked to do a clinical diagnosis of "What am I dealing with here?"
Narrator: In time, 20% of police emergency calls would be for people experiencing acute mental health crises.
Rahsaan Thomas: At the end of the day, they only have the solutions that's on their utility belt.
And those solutions are pepper spray, handcuffs, billy club, stun gun, and a 9-millimeter.
We need way better solutions than that.
Victoria Pratt: There are many ways that people who have mental illness end up in the justice system.
So often, a person ends up in court on a disorderly person's offense, which is causing alarm and a disturbance, which could be screaming at the voices that they're hearing in their head when they're in a public place.
And then they end up in a courtroom.
But then they get charged.
This person should have been sent directly to the hospital.
They get treated as a person who has engaged in wrongful behavior in the criminal justice system, and not as a person who's suffering from mental illness and needs treatment.
Narrator: America's jails and prisons became the nation's largest mental institutions.
Krasner: We have put police, and then correctional officers, in a position of being mental health providers.
And we have put them in the most difficult place you could possibly provide that care, which is prisons that are entirely punitive and don't have features that would allow for deep rehabilitation.
It's a national disaster.
♪ Thomas: I grew up in a neighborhood called Brownsville, Brooklyn.
And, basically, it's 21 housing projects in one small community.
There's projects on both sides of the street for blocks.
I was more of a nerd.
I made computer games on my Commodore 64.
Actually, we all were like that as kids.
We all watched "Star Trek."
We all rode on skateboards and roller skates.
But something happened with them '80s with that drug epidemic, and people stopped collecting comics all of a sudden.
And the neighborhood got different.
It got more intense as our mothers and fathers started getting addicted and getting caught up in the system.
Grandmaster Flash: ♪ Broken glass everywhere ♪ ♪ People ... on the stairs, you know they just don't care ♪ ♪ I can't take the smell, can't take the noise ♪ ♪ Got no money to move out, I guess I got no choice... ♪ Forman Jr.
: These are the Reagan years, so you have cutbacks in social services; so you have a Black community that has always been precarious, right, and is now on the verge of being decimated.
And people are looking for refuge, right?
And that's how crack took hold.
Narrator: Crack was much cheaper and more addictive than powder cocaine, and in the 1980s, it ravaged the poorest urban neighborhoods, bringing with it a spike in crime and violence.
It looked like a whole lost generation, both to the drug because of the addiction but also to the violence that was associated with the drug market.
Ronald Reagan: We live in the midst of a crime epidemic that took the lives of more than 22,000 people last year.
We must make America safe again.
It's time to get these hardened criminals off the street and into jail.
Thomas: If you're growing up and you're poor-- I mean, there's no jobs; You can't find any opportunity anywhere else-- then selling crack makes sense, even though you know everybody that sells crack gets killed or go to prison.
But you're not thinking long range.
I don't think that we need to justify ill behavior because somebody's in a tragic circumstance.
I don't think we want to make excuses for crimes that have been committed, that drug addiction led to child abuse.
It led to domestic violence.
You know, when you sell drugs to fathers and mothers, you do disrupt a family.
I mean, frankly, you do.
[Siren] Reporter: For nearly eighteen months, the drug-related death toll in and around Washington has risen steadily.
Local officials say 80% of the killings arose from disputes in the city's drug trade.
Bratton: In the '80s, we had this explosion of availability of firearms to help the criminal element try to control the drug market.
And the weaponry that they had was increasingly more sophisticated than the six-shot revolver that most American police officers were carrying.
Mangual: My father was an NYPD detective; I think I had my first nightmare about my dad being killed in the line of duty when I was five years old.
I practiced the speech that I would give at his funeral from the time that I was-- I don't know--eight.
It was always a possibility.
When someone in uniform chases an armed suspect through a dark alley, they're running the risk of being shot.
There's honor in that, that people on a municipal salary are taking that kind of risk with their own lives.
And living, you know, in Brooklyn, New York, in the '80s and '90s, we saw crimes happen.
I remember looking out the window and watching somebody get robbed and seeing somebody get slashed.
And it's not pretty.
Stevenson: I can identify hundreds of Zip codes, where 70, 80% of the kids in these Zip codes are going to end up in our criminal justice system.
And that's because they're growing up in places where there's a lot of violence, where there's a lot of shouting, where there's gunshots being fired, where there's a lot of harm and threat and menace.
And their little brains are producing cortisol and adrenaline at rates that are not normal.
They're over-reactive.
They react violently and inappropriately.
Mangual: Unfortunately, there are kids who are exposed to a lot of trauma, and they're living in communities where a lot of that is concentrated.
It kind of creates this sort of reinforcing cycle where, if you don't adopt a propensity for violence, you will be preyed upon.
Thomas: One day, when I was 17 and my little brother was 14 and we were standing in front of the building we grew up in, a neighbor, lived like two blocks away, rolled up on us.
I'm wearing this $600 gold ring with my name, and, like, and diamonds, whatever, right, that I spent all summer saving up for.
And he saw the ring, and he pulled out a .32 revolver and demanded that I run the ring.
And I just tried to grab the gun and tried to fight this guy.
And he started shooting.
And I ran.
And my brother ran.
And then I found out that he was shot in each leg.
And I just felt like the biggest coward in the world.
Like, I ran and left my little brother.
And it just changed me, like, "This has got to stop.
"Like, you all not just going to keep robbing me.
Like, I'd rather die."
And, so, that day, I just changed my mind.
I never carried a gun before that day.
But after that day, I was armed every time you saw me.
♪ Film narrator: When somebody on the outside thinks of prisons or jails or correctional facilities, you know what they think of.
They think of cells, bars, steel doors, fence lines, or walls.
That's security to them.
If you've been in corrections for any length of time, you know that what really keeps inmates in is you, the correctional officer.
All the rest-- the bars and walls-- are just tools you use to help you get the job done.
♪ Stephen B. Walker: No one in elementary school on Career Day raises their hand and says, "I want to be a prison guard."
No.
It's a default.
It's a catch-all occupation.
And in the absence of pay and benefits, you couldn't get people to come to this.
Narrator: Stephen Walker grew up in South Central Los Angeles.
His father worked for the California Department of Corrections.
Walker: I went on to college.
I was pursuing a track career.
I end up being hurt and became demoralized.
You know, when your dreams get dashed, you get lost.
Narrator: In 1984, while attending college and working two jobs, Walker applied to the California Department of Corrections.
Walker: I felt I had limited options.
And this correctional opportunity was a godsend.
I could make good money, have great benefits.
Walker: Back then, training was, These are prisoners; they're not people.
They're numbers to count.
They're entities that have to be moved from point A to point B. Mike Jimenez: When I got into corrections, my training included weapons; it included tactical responses; I was taught that these convicts did something to deserve being here and that you need to not worry about what they did.
You didn't sit on a jury.
So...it's your job to keep them here.
Don't even concern yourself with that stuff.
Walker: If you don't recognize the value of another human being, it is easy to be overly aggressive.
It is easy to be inhumane.
Because you're so focused on the negative of human behavior, it becomes this heightened assessment ability to look at something and recognize the potential harm, hazard, or danger in that setting.
And you're fearful.
And it weighs on you unconsciously.
It extracts from your humanity, and you become jaded.
I was so proficient at dehumanizing them that the staff actually bought me a jacket that said "Robo Cop" on it.
It was about custody and control.
Man: A forced cell move is necessary to remove a hostile and frequently excited inmate from his or her cell.
Exceptionally strong inmates have been able to hold one or two guards out of the cell in the past.
Let's watch this brief but critical procedure in real time.
Nothing the inmate says or does must be allowed to stop the team from securing him and placing him in hand irons and leg irons.
[Officers speaking at once] The number-one man pins the inmate against the rear wall of the cell or on the floor or bed if the inmate falls down.
Officer: Arms secure.
Officer 2: Legs secure.
Narrator: To maintain custody and control, correction officers sometimes turned to leaders inside the prison, who were known as "shot callers."
Thomas: There's no one shot caller at any prison.
There's one for each group of people or each race or each gang or however you want to describe it.
It's easier to talk to a shot caller and get the yard to fall in line than to try to get a whole bunch of individuals to fall in line.
And if it don't get done, then the shot caller is gonna have the person disciplined, which means beat up.
Sometimes you needed those "shot callers" to regulate.
Sometimes you need a level of force that we are incapable of administering without jeopardizing our jobs.
Now, I'm not saying it's right, but it was the culture.
So, anyone causing us headache, heartache, and unnecessary work got dealt with one way or the other.
People assume simply because we're wearing a uniform that we have some immunity to seeing a person hurt, seeing a person in pain.
We attempt to dial that emotional recognition down.
The problem is that you turn that knob so many times, it breaks and you forget how to turn it back up when you walk back out the gates.
And I think that's the reason we see such a high level of substance abuse, of divorce, of suicide for correctional officers.
14 years ago, the followers of Charles Manson murdered seven people in the Tate-LaBianca killings.
A California parole board recently turned down Manson's fifth request for freedom.
Narrator: The infamous cult leader Charles Manson had been sentenced to life in prison in 1972 for one of the most notorious and shocking crimes in the 20th century.
His followers had broken into the Beverly Hills home of actress Sharon Tate and stabbed her and four other people to death.
The next day, they killed two more.
In the early 1980s, Sharon Tate's grieving mother Doris became one of the most prominent victims' rights advocates in the nation.
She found an ally in Assemblyman Pat Nolan.
Nolan: I was very geared towards helping victims.
I still am.
And the stories of victims and their difficulty with the system, the system really isn't victim-oriented.
Their interests are ignored a lot.
Narrator: In 1982, Nolan supported a ballot measure that gave victims the right to participate in parole hearings.
Soon after the proposition passed, Doris Tate began attending parole hearings for the Manson followers who had killed her daughter.
Reporter: Susan Atkins wielded the knife that killed Sharon Tate.
Today, for the sixth time, she went before a parole board to ask for freedom and forgiveness.
How do you ask somebody to forgive you for something that is almost impossible to forgive?
Reporter: Ready to answer, Sharon Tate's mother, now a victims' rights activist.
It was the first time the two had faced each other.
Sharon was sentenced to death without a fair trial or without a jury.
[Sniffles] I was sentenced to life in prison without any possibility of parole.
And I say to you, should Susan Atkins' sentence be any less?
Reporter: The board's response: no parole, prison officials saying she can try again in 3 years.
Mangual: Giving victims a voice in the process, whether by, you know, conferring with them with respect to things like plea deals, giving them an opportunity at sentencing hearings to make an impact statement, all that is important.
And it's important, also, to get it on the record, I think, for the broader public to have an understanding of what is actually involved.
I mean, for people who have never lived in a place where they're likely to have a gun shoved in their face and get robbed, it's very abstract to them.
It's very hard to convey the sense of fear and insecurity and guilt and shame that are created when you are victimized by a stranger.
Krasner: Their voice needs to be heard.
And it is very important to be carefully considered.
But they get a voice.
They don't get a veto.
They are emotionally and personally too close to be allowed to make those kinds of judgements.
Narrator: In 43 states, victims won the right to speak at both parole and sentencing hearings.
Reporter: Stephen McWhorter, who served seven years of a 30-year sentence for manslaughter, has been such a model prisoner, officials here recommended that he be released.
The first vote on this electronic tote board shows parole members were inclined to agree.
Then the victims testified.
This boy shouldn't be released.
He's caused so much pain to my brother.
He's dead.
Reporter: For Stephen McWhorter, parole denied.
Narrator: Many states began granting early release much less frequently, and some abolished parole altogether.
There was a demonstration at the state capitol.
This one was held by the Correctional Peace Officers Association.
They want the justice system changed so we can pay more attention to the needs of crime victims.
Narrator: The victims' rights movement in California worked closely with the prison guards' union, the CCPOA.
Jerry Brown: The correctional officers union funded victim rights groups, so the victim rights groups could be there on the television and talk to the legislators and give their stories about their relatives, their brother, their mother, their father had been murdered.
And this became very powerful.
Walker: It was a benefit to the CCPOA to tie to that bandwagon.
And, look, victims are absolutely an entity that should be recognized, but they were being used to further an agenda by law enforcement, and not just CCPOA.
Because if you look, there are D.A.
organizations, there's the city, county, police that were all tied in on that.
Narrator: The tough on crime policies supported by victims and law enforcement meant that more prisons would be needed.
Brown: Over time, the imperative became, build more prisons.
And, of course, as the legislature built more prisons, every time you build a prison, you needed thousands of more correctional officers, which meant more members to the union, which means more money, which keeps the whole process going.
Narrator: In 1982, the state of California held 34,000 men and women in its prisons.
20 years later, there would be 159,000, nearly five times as many.
To house them, California embarked on what some called the "largest prison-building program in the history of the world."
The state constructed 21 prisons between 1984 and 2005.
The Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation became the biggest agency in the state government, with more than 48,000 employees.
Jimenez: They put prisons in communities that are looking for jobs, that are usually downtrodden communities.
And it isn't just California.
It is nationwide.
At one time, Avenal State Prison, where I worked at, had 8,000 inmates in it.
There were 2,000 people working there.
John Pfaff: Our prisons tend to be rural American jobs programs.
They're, oftentimes, the only middle-class equivalent job in rural parts of the country.
Two-thirds of all of our prison spending is just wages and benefits for correctional officers and staff.
You know, prisons are like the whale, and there are pilot fish all around them.
It's not just the correctional officers, but it's all the food providers, the uniforms, the barbed wire that is plenty lucrative for the people involved.
Krasner: Counties that have lost their coal industry and their steel industry need something to sustain them.
So, having a prison in your county, or two or three or four, becomes the way you pay for your public schools.
It's the way your diner stays open.
It's the way people stay in housing, because they're well-employed.
Narrator: Rural communities gained political power from prisons as well.
Pfaff: A question we face, when someone is in prison and we're drawing our maps for state legislators, where does that person live?
Do they live in the prison, or do they live where they last came from?
Narrator: When apportioning legislative districts, some 40 states counted incarcerated people not in the city or town where they had lived but in the county where the prison that held them was located.
In 48 states, people in prison were not allowed to vote.
Pfaff: The person in prison who cannot vote counts as a full person in that prison for that district.
What this does in states all across the country is move disproportionately Black and Brown men from cities and disenfranchise them in rural areas.
So the prisons move political power.
Man: Join me in welcoming Governor George Deukmejian.
[Applause] Deukmejian: In the 1960s and 1970s, we saw a strong push for alternatives to incarcerating convicted criminals.
While we were trying to understand these criminals, California's crime rate soared.
The residents of this area have realized what others today seem to forget.
And that is that if law-abiding citizens are to be protected, if we are to take the criminals off the streets, then new prisons must be built.
[Applause] ♪ Angelica Zaragoza: I was born in 1978 right in the heart of Dallas, Texas.
What was I like as a young girl?
I was full of life.
I was your chunky little girl with the big cheeks, you know?
Grandma and Grandpa were my main caregivers.
They just loved on me.
Narrator: Angelica Zaragoza lived with her mother, grandparents, and extended family in Pleasant Grove-- a working-class neighborhood in Dallas, Texas.
Zaragoza: I come from a family of incarcerated and addicted.
My mom was in and out of my life.
She was struggling with alcohol and prescription meds.
My dad was nonexistent because he was in and out of prison and an addict as well.
Narrator: When Zaragoza was eight years old, she and her mother moved out of her grandparents' house and went to live with her mother's new husband.
Zaragoza: All of those years were lived in fear of my stepfather.
You know, you had to keep your room correct, you know, you had to do everything, you had to have everything cleaned or, you know, he would get upset and Mom would get-- Mom would get hurt.
She was abused on a daily basis.
I can remember, she was fairly along her pregnancy at this time, and I watched her be pushed down a flight of stairs.
She was afraid to call the police because what happens if he doesn't get taken in, you know?
Narrator: An estimated one in four women in America are victims of domestic violence, but countless incidents go unreported and very few cases go to trial.
Betts: If you want to see where there's a real problem and where it's an American problem, go to the domestic violence docket 'cause you see it all.
You see different races, different genders, different sexualities and all of the kids suffering.
Narrator: Sometimes, Angelica's stepfather shifted his attention to her.
Zaragoza: He would sneak in my room and do things that I didn't want him to do.
And I was scared to say something 'cause I didn't want my mom to get the backlash.
But there was a time that my grandmother came to see me, and she knew something was wrong.
And I did say something.
And my grandmother immediately pulled me out of that house.
But when I got home to Grandma's house, nothing was to be said because Grandpa couldn't find out.
My uncle couldn't find out because there was no telling what they would do.
So, it was something that I just suppressed.
And that's when I started using drugs.
Narrator: Zaragoza graduated from high school, and at 19, she gave birth to a son but was not able to care for him, and sent him to live with his father.
Zaragoza: I got into heroin, and that was a whole nother beast of its own.
It took me from the young, vibrant girl to almost scary at times-- just angry and just hateful, you know.
And some of the things that I did to support that habit, you know, I'm not proud of.
I did everything from steal, rob, sell my body.
Narrator: Zaragoza cycled in and out of the Dallas County jail for five years.
Pratt: For our young girls, being victims of sexual assault, the behavior that they do to protect themselves-- fighting, running away, the use of drugs-- then drives them into the criminal justice system.
Narrator: At 25, Zaragoza was arrested and charged with felony drug possession and prostitution.
She pled guilty.
Zaragoza: I remember getting arrested and finding out that I was three months' pregnant.
And then hearing that you've been sentenced to 18 months in prison, and just the fear of being lost and just not having any control of what's going to happen next.
What am I going to do?
Good evening.
On behalf of the Commission on Presidential Debates, welcome to the second presidential debate.
The candidates are Vice President George Bush, the Republican nominee... [Applause] and Governor Michael Dukakis, the Democratic nominee.
[Applause continues] The first question goes to Governor Dukakis.
You have two minutes to respond.
Governor, if Kitty Dukakis were raped and murdered, would you favor an irrevocable death penalty for the killer?
No, I don't, Bernard.
And I think you know that I've opposed the death penalty during all of my life.
I don't see any evidence that it's a deterrent.
And I think there are better and more effective ways to deal with violent crime.
We've done so in my own state.
Bush: Well, a lot of what this campaign is about, it seems to me, Bernie, goes to a question of values.
And here I do have, on this particular question, a big difference with my opponent.
You see, I do believe that some crimes are so heinous, so brutal, so outrageous, and I'd say particularly those that result in the death of a police officer, those real brutal crimes, I do believe in the death penalty... Narrator: George H.W.
Bush's stance on the death penalty resonated with most Americans, and after the debate, he continued to attack Dukakis for being soft on crime.
Ad narrator: Bush and Dukakis on crime: Bush supports the death penalty for first-degree murderers.
Dukakis not only opposes the death penalty, he allowed first-degree murderers to have weekend passes from prison.
One was Willie Horton, who murdered a boy in a robbery, stabbing him 19 times.
Despite a life sentence, Horton received 10 weekend passes from prison.
Horton fled, kidnapped a young couple, stabbing the man and repeatedly raping his girlfriend.
Weekend prison passes-- Dukakis on crime.
Betts: One of the real problems with Willie Horton is that he allows us to center a conversation around the most violent actor within a system.
He isn't just Willie Horton, the person who committed the crime.
He becomes a representative of every, you know, Black man in America.
Forman Jr.
: I don't think you can overestimate the impact of the Willie Horton ad for a generation of politicians.
It sent the message that if you exercised any amount of discretion in favor of basic humanity towards somebody who is incarcerated-- giving them the right to parole or giving them the right to a day pass, to go to work, if you did anything like that and a crime was committed and it was a Black person who did it, nothing else that you said or did would be remembered by the populace.
What would be remembered is that you were soft on crime.
And so, this set in motion this bipartisan bidding War for criminal justice harshness.
What are we going to do?
Just let all these hardened criminals go because we don't have the guts to do what's right, to incarcerate them and make them serve the time that they need to serve?
I hope not.
I don't care why someone is antisocial.
I don't care why they become a sociopath.
We have an obligation to cordon them off from the rest of society, try to help them, try to change their behavior.
But they are in jail, away from my mother, your husband, our families.
Word unfolded in Sacramento today of what may turn into a major corruption scandal in the California State Legislature.
Late last night, more than two dozen FBI agents armed with search warrants invaded the Capitol and began searching legislative offices for evidence.
Reporter: The Republican Assembly Leader, Pat Nolan of Glendale, is one of the officials under investigation.
Narrator: In 1988, Pat Nolan was the target of an FBI sting operation.
Federal prosecutors charged him with racketeering, extortion, conspiracy to commit extortion, and money laundering.
Each offense carried a mandatory minimum sentence.
If found guilty of all charges, Nolan faced up to 20 years in prison.
He maintained his innocence.
Nolan: When I was prosecuted, my children were five years old, four years old, and just ten months.
And I faced the prospect of being away from them their entire childhood with those stacked mandatory minimums, so I took this plea.
Narrator: In exchange for his guilty plea, Nolan was sentenced to 33 months in federal prison.
Nolan: There's no sound like it... [Slam] when that gate clangs behind you and you're theirs.
You're stripped, obviously, of your family, your work, your friends, your church, and you're tossed into a roiling cauldron of anger and bitterness, sexual frustration, violence.
You're stripped of any ability to defend yourself.
There's a lot of despair.
Satan stalks the halls.
And that's where my faith actually helped me 'cause the only light in prison were from the religious services we had, the Bible studies.
Narrator: Pat Nolan was released after serving 25 months.
He remained as politically conservative as he had been before he went to prison, but when it came to crime and punishment, his thinking had changed.
He went to work for the Prison Fellowship, a non-profit Christian organization, and became one of the country's most influential conservative advocates for criminal justice reform.
Nolan: I believe we need prisons, but not everybody that breaks a law belongs in prison.
It's our default punishment, and that doesn't make sense.
It certainly is harmful to them, their family, whatever future they have.
As a people, it's very expensive to the taxpayers.
These people have value, and we are wasting God's creation by treating them this way and throwing them in the dustbin.
[Indistinct police radio transmissions] Thomas: When it comes to the police, I felt like they didn't care about me.
When my mom got robbed, nothing happened.
When our apartment got burglarized three different times, nothing happened.
The police didn't catch anybody.
When my brother got shot, I didn't cooperate with the police.
I didn't show up for any of that stuff.
Why would I cooperate with a system that's going to make me go to court, go through all this drama and all this trouble?
And at the end of the day, you can get a deal for somewhere between six months and five years, and be back home with more muscles and calling me a snitch and looking for me.
And then how is that going to help me?
But I still hoped they locked this guy up because it was dangerous for us to be in the same neighborhood together.
And I knew if I saw him, I would kill him.
And I knew if he saw me, he might kill me.
And, so, we couldn't be in the same neighborhood together.
We needed to be separated.
And I didn't know how that was going to happen.
I just hoped it happened through policing.
And it didn't.
Six months later, he waved the same gun at me that he shot my little brother with.
I had to make a decision that day, and I shot him.
Thank God he didn't die, but he went to the hospital.
And that's how the police caught him.
He had seven warrants out on him for robbing and shooting people in my neighborhood.
And he wasn't on the run.
He was on a corner.
So, I felt like the police don't give a damn about me.
And if I ain't take justice, I'd never be able to get it or receive it in this country.
But it did not satisfy me.
I became what I hated.
So, I can tell you from personal experience, revenge destroys you.
[Theme music playing] Good evening from Washington.
I'm John Walsh, and welcome to a very special edition of "America's Most Wanted."
It was supposed to be a slumber party for Polly and two of her closest friends, but instead, it turned into something unimaginable.
I ran into the bedroom, and Polly wasn't there.
I said, "Where's Polly?
Where's Polly?"
Narrator: In October of 1993, in Petaluma, California, a 12-year-old girl named Polly Klaas was kidnapped from her home.
Jess Nichol: Polly was a beautiful girl.
There's a part of me that was lost when Polly was kidnapped.
When I was 13, to know that such a horrific thing could happen, like, it really, it was very shocking.
To have this kind of crime where somebody comes in through a back door and takes her from her bedroom, it really touched a nerve for a lot of people.
Walsh: News of Polly's abduction set off an instant call to action in Petaluma... Narrator: Law enforcement and volunteers searched for Polly for two months.
Reporters from all across the nation descended on Petaluma.
In November, acting on a tip, police arrested a suspect.
Richard Allen Davis had served eight years in California's prisons for robbery, kidnapping, and assault, and he was out on parole.
Davis led police to Polly's body.
The people of Petaluma, California, are doing something tonight they had hoped they wouldn't have to do.
Investigators in California are looking for evidence in the closed-off area where the body of 12-year-old Polly Klaas... And a community is trying to cope with its grief.
Reporter: It was an emotional Marc Klaas who held his first news conference since his daughter was confirmed dead.
Marc: My beautiful daughter Polly is dead.
America's child is dead.
Annie Nichol: The attention that we received made healing and grieving harder for us.
I think that there's something really harmful about turning trauma into entertainment.
And today with true crime, it's a really strange thing that makes people feel entitled to your pain, entitled to, like, sordid details about the worst thing that ever happened to you.
Narrator: David was found guilty of murder and sent to death row.
Wilson: This animal should never have been at large on the streets of California.
Our streets are being stained with the blood of our children.
And it's got to stop.
Damn it, it's got to stop.
So, I ask you, please, work with me to pass tougher laws.
We know what California needs to make our cities, our suburbs, and our small towns safe again.
We should start with the Three Strikes, You're Out bill.
Reporter: The concept is no slack for three-time felons-- three strikes and you're out, automatically sentenced to 25 years to life.
It would have kept in prison Richard Allen Davis, the parolee accused of the kidnap and murder of the 12-year-old Petaluma girl Polly Klaas.
Narrator: Politicians all across the country were calling for Three Strikes laws.
Reporter: Fellow Democrats, like New York Governor Mario Cuomo, who's running for a fourth term, seem determined to be just as tough on crime as the Republicans have traditionally been.
In baseball, it's three strikes and you're out.
In dealing with violent crime, it should be three strikes and you're in...permanently.
Jess Nichol: The feeling I got was, this was going to be a good thing, that it was going to prevent harm like happened to Polly from happening to other kids.
Justice was served in our case.
They found the man who killed our sister.
He went on trial.
He got a death sentence.
Legislation was passed in our family's name.
That's "justice."
We are, we--that is the model.
But we actually felt entirely unmet in our needs as survivors.
It felt like we were tricked.
NBC News in depth tonight-- crime and punishment in California.
The state's tough law that locks up repeat offenders for life.
But critics are now saying the three strikes law goes too far.
Reporter: Dwayne Williams' third felony conviction was for stealing a slice of pizza.
Jed Miller was tried and convicted of stealing a bike, his third conviction.
The biggest Third Strike crime categories: 3,749 people sentenced for drug possession, 1,959 sentenced for petty theft, 1,461 for second-degree burglary.
Only 40 murderers and 25 rapists have been sent away under Three Strikes.
Narrator: Thousands of men and women in California would be given the mandatory minimum sentence of 25 years to life.
Many of those convicted had mental illnesses or intellectual disabilities.
Black people made up 5% of the state's population and 45% of those convicted of a "third strike."
Annie Nichol: It does feel like Three Strikes was this extension and amplification of our suffering as a family that got passed on to tens of thousands of people to pay for.
Betts: I don't know if we should blame the victims of crimes who want vengeance when we have given them nothing in return.
I think vengeance becomes a proxy for wholeness.
But vengeance is never justice.
Jess Nichol: Feeling angry, feeling vengeful is a really healthy process, part of a healing process.
And it's really important to feel anger and rage, actually.
But when we take a victim and they're in that moment and then that person is then used to pass legislation, to advocate for legislation to happen based on their feelings of vengeance for their case, I just, I believe that is completely inappropriate.
If punishment is all that you're offered as a victim, if it's all that you're taught you can ask for or expect, I understand wanting it.
But what if more options were available?
And what if we had a justice system that wasn't just focused on punishing people who did harm but was actually focused on helping victims?
[Cell door shuts] Zaragoza: My first time going to prison, it was so lonely, full of fear of the unknown.
When I was pregnant and three times bigger than my normal body, I still was expected to sleep on this thin mat.
And food in there is, it's horrible.
You don't get the milk.
You don't get the greens.
You don't get the things that your body needs to feed this baby, you know?
I can remember the baby pulling so much from me that I started losing my teeth.
And then I remember going into labor, and I had to have one foot shackled to the bars.
I remember feeling like an animal almost.
And then you got to hold your baby for 15 minutes and then you had to let them go.
I can remember, after I had her--it was a few months-- and I would wake up in these dreams, where I could literally hear this baby crying.
Narrator: Zaragoza's Aunt Janie agreed to take custody of her daughter Jalyssa.
Zaragoza: You know, my aunt, she has a full-time job of her own.
The prison was 2 1/2, 3 hours away.
It easily makes for a whole-day commute, so she was able to come out maybe once every three months, you know, maybe twice a year.
When the family was able to come to visit, it's one hug in, one hug out.
Your family sits across a table from you.
It's basically a conversation from one side of the table to the other.
Narrator: Like Zaragoza, most women behind bars in America are mothers.
Zaragoza: A mother, her children are her everything.
And just knowing that I lost those children, it took the hope out of me, out of my world.
But the volunteers that would come in, they would treat us like humans.
They would care to listen how our day was going or who our children were.
Narrator: Volunteers with a non-profit, the Women's Storybook Project, helped Zaragoza and other mothers record themselves reading books, and sent the tapes to their children.
[Button clicks] Zaragoza on recording: "'The Invisible String.'
"Liza and Jeremy, the twins, were asleep one calm and quiet night..." Zaragoza: I wasn't able to see my oldest son.
He lived with his dad, but I had the opportunity to mail him this tape, and maybe he wouldn't lose the comfort of knowing that I-- just 'cause I'm not there doesn't mean that I don't love him.
That little thing that I did really helped.
Zaragoza on recording: "As they slept, they started dreaming "of all the invisible strings they have.
"And from deep inside they now could clearly see: no one is ever alone."
Man: Mr.
Speaker, the president of the United States.
[Cheering and applause] Narrator: Bill Clinton, the first Democrat to be elected president since 1976, made fighting crime one of his top priorities.
In 1993, the year he assumed office, 24,526 people were murdered in America.
Violent crime and the fear it provokes are crippling our society, limiting personal freedom, and fraying the ties that bind us... Narrator: Clinton championed the most sweeping federal crime legislation in American history, the Violent Crime Control and Law Enforcement Act.
The bill included an assault weapons ban, the Violence Against Women Act, a Three Strikes provision for federal crimes, and a ban on prisoners receiving Pell grants for higher education.
$9.7 billion was allocated for prison construction, and $8.8 billion to put an additional 100,000 police officers on the nation's streets.
Clinton worked hard to build support for the bill.
Peter Jennings: Now, there have been some pretty trying events on your watch in the year and the bit since you've been president, and one of them occurred in California, and we have a young lady here this morning.
Hi, Annie.
Annie Nichol: Well, the other day, I asked my mom, "Do you think I'm going to live to grow up?"
And my sister Polly didn't live to grow up, so I didn't feel that safe.
Let me say, first of all, you're a brave girl to come here and let us see your story.
Annie Nichol, voice-over: I can't remember who told me to say what I said, but I was given a political message without having the ability to understand it or to understand the impact of it.
I was just this little girl grieving for her murdered sister, telling the president to punish people.
Clinton: You know, I have a little girl, too.
I want the children of this country to be able to grow up on safe streets and safe schools and safer homes.
And that's why we're working on some laws to identify people who are serious threats to society, who will likely repeat their crimes, and not let them out.
A second thing we have to do is... As an American police chief, I'd like to say thank you to the president.
I've been in this business for 23 years, and for the first time, I'm sensing a fear among American police forces, a fear that we are losing the streets.
Bratton, voice-over: The bill had many good features.
I was very proud to have been part of its development and implementation.
It was something that was needed at that time.
James Clyburn: Mr.
Speaker, I rise today as a voice for the millions of Americans who are equally frightened and frustrated by the senseless wave of violence that has gripped our nation.
I believe that all factors considered, this bill is a--is a step in the right direction.
Narrator: The bill passed with overwhelming bipartisan support.
President Clinton signed it on the South Lawn, with Polly Klaas' father looking on.
Clinton: This bill puts government on the side of those who abide by the law, not those who break it... Narrator: When the crime bill passed, there were one million people in prison-- five times as many as there had been in 1970.
Pfaff: The story people grab onto is that the '94 crime bill is to blame for the explosion in U.S.
prison population.
That is a very simple, incorrect story.
In fact, if you look from about 1972 to around 2000, you can almost draw the line with a ruler.
It's just a steady, straight, unrelenting, slow rise.
This wasn't just some sort of one-off event.
This was something much deeper and much more cultural and much more social and much more embedded in who we are.
Mangual: Part of why we have a higher incarceration rate is not just the fact that we have so much more serious crime, but we also have more of the resources available to detect that crime and to mete out punishment.
We have a robust criminal justice system, where almost every--not almost, where every major city has a police department.
And then we have prosecutors who are paid good salaries and, you know, dedicate a number of years to public service where they are churning the system.
Pfaff: In the 1990s and 2000s, we dramatically staffed up D.A.
offices, especially in the major cities that handle most of our cases.
We just have thousands and thousands and more of them than we did in the '80s and '70s.
And they chose to simply start charging more and more people who were being arrested with felonies and sending more and more of them to prison.
Krasner: I've noticed this pattern, which has been that five is the new one.
The kind of offense that used to get you a year all of a sudden became five.
You know, it's as if five became a metric for a shorter sentence.
And, so, five years became 25 and 10 years became 50.
It was this ratcheting up, which was based on no science and no cost-benefit analysis, but it also sort of became this cultural thing.
Pratt: Punishment absolutely needs to be proportional.
The problem is that we have not seen proportional punishment in the United States.
And because our punishment is disproportionate, we create two victims-- the person who's been harmed and then the person that we've now disproportionately punished.
Bratton: By the end of the decade, the 1990s, the jail population and prison population went up.
There's no denying that a large part of that increase were minority, young men in particular.
That was the reality of crime in America, unfortunately, at that time.
So, it's like a doctor when he's giving you treatment for serious cancer.
You hope you have a good doctor who's not going to kill you with overtreatment of radiation or chemo.
You're going to get sick for a while, but then you're going to, basically, get better.
♪ Thomas: In my mid-20s, I got into the criminal life.
The trauma of my little brother getting shot in front of me and me always constantly trying to make up for running, prove that I'm not a coward over and over again, in every confrontation.
I just kept going in this pattern where somebody would do something that maybe we could just talk it out, but my response would be negative, would be violent.
I did two years, and I came home with a felony.
I just didn't find a path to a good job.
I had jobs, but they were jobs, they weren't a career.
And, mind you, now at 22, I had a kid and then another kid, and just life kept happening.
And I just vowed that I would never be like my father, I would always be part of my kids' life.
Because my father, he was never around.
But I was still trying to figure it out, trying to struggle and get it together, and I started selling drugs.
I started doing that at first with one foot in and one foot out.
Like, I'm just gonna hustle enough with this drug stuff to make it so I can get my family out the ghetto.
And it just didn't work out like that.
Like, once you put a foot in, you get pulled into that life.
And it's not easy work.
It's fast money, but it's dangerous work.
The thing about drugs, you have to defend it.
You know, there's people that won't rob a regular person, but they'll rob a drug dealer because it's illegal money anyway and that's how they justify committing robbery, right?
Narrator: At 28, Rahsaan Thomas left New York for Southern California, hoping to make it in the music business.
But not long after he got there, he agreed to help a friend sell thousands of dollars' worth of marijuana.
The meeting unraveled when the buyers tried to rob them.
Thomas: I went there with a loaded gun.
And then when the moment of truth came, I had a choice.
I could just say, "Take it.
It ain't worth it.
You can have it.
Take it."
Instead I took a life, and there's no excuse for that.
None.
Narrator: Thomas was found guilty of attempted manslaughter and second-degree murder.
He was sentenced to 55 years to life.
Thomas: When I end up in prison for life, I realized I was gonna miss my whole entire sons' lives... and I was worse than my father.
[Wu-Tang Clan's "C.R.E.A.M."
playing] ♪ Betts: I grew up in Prince George's County, Maryland, right outside of D.C.
I have a few friends from that time period that I still have.
And some of us still share a love of books that we read in seventh grade and eighth grade together.
I was a good student, and I didn't live in a reflection of the streets of whatever rap song I might have been listening to.
Wu-Tang Clan: ♪ A man with a dream ♪ ♪ With plans to make C.R.E.A.M., which failed ♪ ♪ I went to jail at the age of 15 ♪ ♪ A young buck sellin' drugs and such who never had much... ♪ Most of the people I grew up with didn't go to prison.
Most of them didn't commit crimes.
But I had friends who sold drugs.
I knew that my mom was actively trying to keep me away from all of these things.
You know, I lived in a community that had all of the ingredients for the life that I would want to give my child, but it also had all of the ingredients for some small subsection of us to believe that a pistol was the pathway towards... power or authority or a new pair of sneakers.
Narrator: In 1996, Reginald Dwayne Betts was a junior in high school.
He was 16-years old, 5'5" tall, and still had braces on his teeth.
Betts was an honor student, class treasurer, had never been in trouble with the law, had never held a gun.
I was with a group of friends.
Somebody said they had a money problem, and I suggested we rob somebody.
And then happenstance brought somebody in the room that actually had a gun.
And then we got in a car, and we drove off.
We went to Springfield Mall in suburban Virginia, and I carjacked a man who was asleep in his car.
I got arrested on December 8, 1996.
And almost immediately, after they placed handcuffs on me, I confessed.
I think, for me, the most harrowing moment of my incarceration was having to call my mom and tell her I did it.
My mom and my aunts and my uncles, even if they loved me, they didn't recognize me anymore when they contemplated me with a pistol in my hand, carjacking somebody.
And all of a sudden, I reminded them of the things they feared the most.
[Indistinct police radio transmissions] Reporter: As you watch these pictures, consider this... [Boy yells] there's a tidal wave of juvenile violent crime right over the horizon.
The experts tell us that by the year 2000, there'll be a huge increase in the number of 14- to 17-year-old boys.
And barring some miracle, that will translate into what's being called the mother of all crime waves.
The next generation of young criminals, we're told, will be more dangerous and more violent than anything we've ever seen in this country.
There's even a name for them: superpredators.
John DiIulio: A superpredator is a young, juvenile criminal, who is so impulsive, so remorseless that he can kill, rape, maim without giving it a second thought.
Narrator: The superpredator theory advanced by professor John DiIulio was embraced by the media, law enforcement, and politicians.
They are not just gangs of kids anymore.
They are often the kinds of kids that are called "superpredators": no conscience, no empathy.
We can talk about why they ended up that way, but first, we have to bring them to heel.
And the president is... Forman Jr.
: Policymakers took that idea and they said, "We'll push young people out of juvenile court into adult court."
The theory had these incredibly damaging impacts.
There are people still serving sentences because of it.
Every state in the country starts putting younger and younger children in jails and prisons.
So I sometimes represent nine-year-old children facing adult prison for non-homicide offenses.
Narrator: In the 1990s, tens of thousands of teenagers-- nearly half of them Black-- were tried as adults.
Ten were eventually put to death.
Children as young as 13 were sentenced to life in prison.
2,225 were given life without the possibility of parole.
Betts: I don't know what--what age I think that it's, like, OK to say that, you know, "You are now doomed to a cell for the rest of your life."
As a teenager, your brain isn't fully developed.
You know, you don't have the maturity.
We shouldn't think about the crime you committed as indicative of you being incorrigible.
We should try some different way to think about what it is that you've done.
I mean, my mom knew that.
We all know that for our children.
Narrator: At 16, Betts was charged as an adult.
Betts: When I realized that I was going to be tried as an adult and that carjacking carried life in prison, I understood that my world had radically changed.
Narrator: Betts was sentenced to nine years in prison.
I always knew that being young wasn't an excuse.
But it was only now that I think fully about what I did... and how many of those steps were intentional.
Everybody says, "Why'd you do it?"
And it's, like, "If you want me to be honest, I have to say I don't have a reason."
And people are, like, "Well, you have to have a reason."
It's like, "We never have reasons, never good ones."
Forman Jr.
: It turns out that the superpredator theory was wrong.
It was all wrong.
At the time that the theory was being announced, the crime rates, including crime rates by young people, were beginning to decline, right?
Nobody knew it yet, because you don't know that crime is going to begin to decline in 1995 until it's '98 or '99 and you can look and see that there's a trend.
Crime had already begun to decline and would continue to decline.
Narrator: The "mother of all crime waves" that experts had predicted never came to pass.
Instead of rising, violent crime rates dropped all across the country.
It was called the "great crime decline."
Some believed that law enforcement and incarceration were largely responsible.
Mangual: We decided that we were going to police more aggressively.
We decided that we were going to treat criminals more harshly and that more of them were going to go to jail and prison.
We made those choices, and those choices yielded benefits that were enjoyed by everybody to a degree, but they were most enjoyed by low-income minority communities.
Narrator: But there were many other theories about what caused the crime decline: demographic trends, the job market, increased access to birth control and abortion, lower levels of lead pollution, and violence-prevention initiatives.
No one knew for sure why it happened.
Pfaff: All these things probably matter here and there.
Some cities change their policing tactics.
Some cities don't.
Crime goes down in both.
No one thing seems to be "the" explanation.
And I think we still struggle to sort of piece together a clear understanding of exactly what--what happened.
Narrator: Violent crime rates remained far below where they had been in the early 1990s, but incarceration continued to climb.
By 2008, there were 1,600,000 people in prison in America.
Millions more were in jail or on parole or probation.
On any given night, 1% of all adults in the United States were behind bars.
Some began to call what was happening mass incarceration.
Stevenson: We've spent billions of dollars putting millions of people in jails and prisons, taking funding from health and human services, taking funding from education, taking funding from infrastructure.
Narrator: More people were locked away in the United States per capita than in any other country.
In Japan, there were 63 per 100,000.
In Germany, 88, in the United Kingdom, 151, in America, 751 per 100,000.
Mangual: The idea that we are a overly punitive carceral nation, I just don't think stands up to that scrutiny.
There is a reason why we incarcerate at such a significantly higher degree.
And that is because we have more crime and more serious violent crime.
Krasner: We could talk about other countries.
For example, Germany, you find that the approach is strictly rehabilitative.
And they had about 20% of our rate of homicide.
Way fewer people in jail, way safer.
They regard it as failure to have to put somebody in prison for the rest of their life, to not be able to come up with a course of action that restores that person.
Krasner: It even goes so far as inmates drive home, have dinner with their families, drive back, and sleep in the prison.
Unthinkable in the United States that we would actually preserve family bonds.
But what happens when you try to keep these protective factors in play, you try to rehabilitate people instead of breaking them and crushing them?
What happens is you have a much safer society and you have a much freer society.
Betts: By the time I came home from prison, I had spent a third of my life in prison.
I applied for a job at a paint store.
And it had this question on the application that said, "Have you been convicted of a felony in the past seven years?"
And it's the only time I ever thanked my judge.
[Laughs] I was, like, "Man, he sentenced me to nine years in prison."
And I could honestly say no, right?
And he gave me the job.
And I didn't understand, really, at first, how lucky I was until a few months later.
Somebody else came into my actual place of employment, fresh out of the DC jail, and he said, you know, "I just came out of the jail, and I'm trying to change my life."
And it was him and a friend of his, and the manager let him fill out the application and then balled it up and threw it in a trash can when they left.
Narrator: Reginald Dwayne Betts went to college, earned a master's degree in creative writing and a law degree from Yale.
He published four books of poetry, received a MacArthur Fellowship, and founded Freedom Reads-- an organization dedicated to providing books and installing libraries in prisons.
But hundreds of thousands of men and women who are released from prison every year still struggle to find work and a place to live.
Within three years, more than half end up back behind bars, often for violating the terms of their parole.
Krasner: So, there are deep evils to having excessive supervision.
Supervision in the criminal justice context usually means being on probation or being on parole.
It provides an opportunity for the tiniest things to become trip wires that would put people back in custody.
They're going to smoke a little weed, they're going to miss one appointment, they're going to miss paying for their own supervision-- something like that that's going to put them back.
On a monthly basis, you have to pay the state's fees; you have to pay Crimestoppers.
You have to pay for your urine analysis to prove that you're not using.
When you don't pay these, that just stacks and stacks and stacks.
Narrator: After she was released from prison, Angelica Zaragoza struggled with addiction and was arrested again on burglary charges.
Facing up to 25 years, she pled guilty in exchange for ten years' probation.
Zaragoza became sober.
But with a felony conviction, she couldn't find a job.
Eventually, she stopped paying her fees.
She was charged with violating her probation.
Zaragoza: And they just wanted to send me back to prison or they actually wanted to put me on three more years of probation, which was going to stack up even more fees.
And I told the judge, "All you're going to do is "put me in more debt.
"Give me a job.
I'll pay your fees if you help me get a job."
And then that's when it was, "Well, then we'll just send you back for two years."
So, then I had to make that difficult call.
Narrator: Zaragoza decided to go back to prison.
She left behind four children, including her 11-year-old daughter.
Zaragoza: I was determined not to leave that prison system the way I went in.
I had heard of this program where they bring your daughter to visit you once a month.
And I can remember the first few visits that she came, it was totally silent.
She was hurt.
She was mad.
But during this one visit, we were doing this craft, and she couldn't figure it out.
And I remember her turning to me and she said, "Mom, will you help me?"
And that was when I found my hope again, when my baby girl was just asking me for help.
And visit after visit, things got better.
We started laughing.
We started talking.
And the bonding started happening.
Narrator: After Zaragoza was released, she went to work for the non-profit that had helped her reconnect with her daughter.
Zaragoza: That's what my purpose is today.
I have found it in taking those moms' hope back inside those walls and offering them a chance to make a change from the inside out.
It keeps me humble, and it keeps me fighting for a better way for the next person.
Thomas: If you committed a crime and are convicted of that crime, is that who you are for the rest of your life?
Even if you've changed, even if that was the first time you ever did that crime, you are labeled by that.
And how do you change if no one ever sees you but for what you've done for your worst act?
Narrator: Rahsaan Thomas spent ten years in maximum security prisons in California.
In 2013, he was transferred to San Quentin, a medium-security facility that had more rehabilitative programs than any other prison in the state.
Thomas: At the time, I had 55 to life, I was never going home.
And within a week, I was signed up for everything.
Within a month, I was in creative writing.
By August, I was the sports editor for "San Quentin News."
And so I just really dived in.
Narrator: Thomas also became a producer on "Ear Hustle," a podcast created inside San Quentin.
The best thing about San Quentin wasn't just the groups and the college and all the opportunities, it's the people.
I became part of the community.
I met this lady named Ayula.
She came in for a victim-offender dialogue.
She had two different sons gunned down on two different days, and she told about 30 men convicted of life sentences, violent crimes, about her sons being gunned down, and it broke our hearts.
Like, there wasn't a dry eye in the place.
You had 30 men-- supposed to be hardcore-- crying in that room, feeling her pain.
And it was the first time I felt remorse 'cause for a lot of years, I justified what I did.
And so I couldn't feel remorse for the human being that I killed.
To know that it's your fault, that all of that death, all that pain that you not only caused his family but your own family.
You murdered your own family's dreams for you, you murdered your own son's right to a father.
To know that you're responsible for all that and there's no excuse is the hardest thing in the world to ever face.
These are the things that got to my humanity and made me feel real, real remorse and changed my life.
It wasn't the bars; it wasn't the punishment.
Narrator: Rahsaan Thomas was granted parole and released from prison in 2023.
He became a filmmaker and a writer.
I'm definitely sorry for the harm I caused, definitely sorry for taking a life and causing that man's family pain.
And so I'm just--I hope that I'm allowed to continue in peace, to make a impact on the future, and know that that's motivated, that that death, that harm was not in vain.
It's my fuel.
It's why I get up every day and try to have a positive impact every single day.
That's my way of saying sorry.
♪ Narrator: 250 years after the United States was founded, Americans continue to wrestle with the problem of crime, the purpose of punishment, and the meaning of justice.
Nolan: We are a great nation, and we have high ideals.
We're letting our people down and our ideals down by continuing this incarceration explosion.
Americans believe in redemption, very strongly.
And so there's a disconnect there.
And I think one of our tasks is to make it clear, yes, these people have done terrible things, but we have an obligation to try to help them turn their lives around.
Mangual: There are individuals, who, through their repeated criminal conduct, make very, very clear that they don't have any intention of playing by society's rules.
That's why I think we need to push for harsher sentences for the kind of offenders that, again, establish their propensity very early on.
So, it's not about writing someone off or, you know, relegating them to the dustbin.
It's about the public being victimized by somebody who never should have been on the street, not writing off the other, more promising members of the community who deserve life and peace and safety.
I am not the person who's gonna say that, you know, we should just have a society that doesn't have any prisons at all.
You want a place to put people who somehow threaten the safety and the sanctity and the peace of a community.
I think that we have to have a system that allows people to feel protected and safe.
[Cell door shuts] But I also think that those places should not be places of torment.
And I think that we can say that that needs to change while you radically find ways to let more and more and more people go.
Walker: You can never make up for some harms.
The scale simply cannot be balanced.
And time is no recompense for a life lost.
I lost my brother to a young man that was driving under the influence.
That young man sitting in a cell being away from his family doesn't bring me any comfort.
I suppose part of the question of justice is helping that individual understand how not to repeat the harm that they've caused.
I don't know what that looks like, but I know what it doesn't look like.
And it doesn't look like the system that we have today.
[Indistinct chatter] Narrator: Many have come to question the cost-- and the consequences-- of being tough on crime.
Formerly incarcerated men and women have led campaigns for the repeal of three-strikes laws and mandatory minimums and for ending solitary confinement.
In some states, they won back the right to vote, a right that had historically been denied to anyone convicted of a felony.
Some politicians in both parties have agreed to roll back some of the harshest policies, and the prison population has begun to shrink.
Jess Nichol: We know that harsh sentences do not make us safe.
We also know that harsh sentences do not help us heal.
Narrator: Some crime victims and survivors, including Jess and Annie Nichol, have championed less punitive, more restorative approaches to justice.
Annie Nichol: We are here today to reimagine a justice system that serves more victims than it creates, that cares more about preventing harm than punishing people.
Activist: What do we want?
Crowd: Healing!
When do we want it?
Now!
What do we want?
Healing!
When do we want it?
Annie Nichol, voice-over: Harm never really happens in a vacuum, and harm is something that creates crime.
Harm is something that is created by crime and by our justice system.
If we don't help people heal, we can't prevent that harm from continuing and hurting someone else.
Betts: This question of justice is a wild problem.
When you think about the hardest part about it, you have to ask yourself, "What would you do if it was your child?"
You know, "What would you do if it was somebody you loved?"
And you default to vengeance because what else do you have left?
Or you default to mercy because you decide that no matter how horrific and messy and human a world is, it can be a little bit more beautiful.
And we all deserve a world that is governed by mercy and not one that's governed by vengeance.
♪ ♪ Announcer: Scan this QR code with your smart device to dive deeper into the story of "Crime and Punishment in America" with interactives, classroom materials, and more.
Announcer: The "Crime and Punishment in America" DVD is available online and in stores.
The series is also available with PBS Passport and on Amazon Prime Video.
The digital companion soundtrack is also available online.
♪ ♪ ♪ Announcer: Major funding for "Crime and Punishment in America" was provided by... The Atlantic Philanthropies, Emerson Collective, The Andrew W. Mellon Foundation, and the Park Foundation.
Major funding was also provided by the following members of The Better Angels Society: The Fullerton Family Charitable Fund, The Just Trust for Education, Allan and Shelley Holt, The Tow Foundation, and the Sozosei Foundation.
Additional support was provided by the National Endowment for the Humanities, The Arthur Vining Davis Foundations, and by The Better Angels Society members: John and Catherine Debs, Timothy Fazio, Lise Strickler and Mark Gallogly, the Laurie M. Tisch Illumination Fund, and these additional funders.
"Crime and Punishment in America" was made possible, in part, by contributions to your PBS station from Viewers Like You.
Thank you.
Support for PBS provided by:
Episodes presented in 4K UHD on supported devices. Major funding for CRIME AND PUNISHMENT IN AMERICA was provided by The Atlantic Philanthropies, Emerson Collective, The Andrew W. Mellon Foundation, and...
















